The Battalion. (College Station, Tex.) 1893-current, January 21, 1983, Image 16
S £86l ' IZ AJEnuE[ 'Aepuj uoyeuefl ^Ml testr^ ly Fast fat loss unhealthy THE KEY IS to lose WEI6HT SLOWLY. SO I'tt OH THE MOLASSES DIET..' by Kathy Breard Battalion Staff One of the more popular New Year's resolutions is to lose weight — a goal most want to achieve as soon as possible. But diet experts around the Texas A&M campus favor a slow, gradual weight loss for people who really want to keep weight off. The quickie dieters usually are disappointed because they may lose the 10 pounds they've al ways dreamed of losing, but are likely to gain it back. Society's attitude toward peo ple who are overweight encour ages emotional stress. Many Americans want to be thin, and it's a national obsession to look like the skinny fashion models in magazines. Americans favor the "22— year—old concept," which means everyone should look as lean and trim as a young adult, Dr. William A. McIntosh, asso ciate professor of sociology at Texas A&M, says. But in Asian and European societies, overweight people are more readily accepted. In fact, some of these societies prefer a heftier frame. In some African societies, women are sent off to be "fattened up" before their wedding day. The concept of the perfect body has changed in the last 20 years, and many of the women of average weight on Texas A&M's campus would be consi dered underweight in a Euro pean culture. Dr. Kerry Hope, a psychologist with the Texas A&M Student Counseling Ser vice, says. Students on Texas A&M's campus have experimented with several diets and voice their opinions on the effective ness of some reducing plans. Juliana Hunsaker, an elemen tary education major from Houston, who has tried several diets, including the Scarsdale Diet, says Weight Watchers is the best diet she's ever found. Hunsaker says she didn't keep off the 10 pounds she lost last semester through the Weight Watchers program, but with self—discipline it would have had better results. "I go on binges and I don't want to miss out when my friends go out to eat," she says. Weight Watchers is an eating program that allows a person to eat a variety of foods while fol lowing a basic meal plan. "I like Weight Watchers be cause it teaches you to eat in a natural, healthy way," Hunsak er says. However, she takes a dimmer view of the Scarsdale Diet. "It was a pain because I had to buy special food, and I couldn't substitute different foods like I could in Weight Watchers," she says. The Scarsdale Diet is a low fat, low carbohydrate diet of 1,000 calories or less per day. The diet is limited to 14 days, and allows for a variety of food combina tions, but no substitutes. Some of the dieters inter viewed wished to remain anonymous because they con sider dieting a personal problem. Kim, who recently moved to Bryan from Colorado, says she likes Weight Watchers for the positive attitude she gets from it. "Weight Watchers never mentions being skinny — it's just a matter of feeling good ab out yourself," Kim says. But to feel good about them selves, many people think they have to be skinny, or at least should be on some drastic diet. So, they look for a "magic diet" with the quickest, easiest methods of reducing weight. You've probably heard them all, ranging from starving your self to drinking liquid protein. But just how effective are these diets, and are they safe to use? Local experts have some sug gestions for finding a suitable diet. "Any diet will result in weight loss if the amount of energy eaten is less than the amount used," says Karen Kubena, a Texas A&M assistant professor of food science and nutrition. "The problem is keeping that weight off." "A sensible weight loss plan provides adequate vitamins, minerals, and a steady loss of 1 to 2 pounds a week — if the diet meets these requirements, it's probably not just a fad." Many diets claim to carry all the needed nutrients, but some tend to cause a much more rapid weight loss than a couple of pounds a week. That's danger ous for some people, Hope says. People need a wide variety of meats with protein, as well as fruits and vegetables. Another fact to consider is that people don't absorb all the vitamins they eat in the course of a day, Kubena says. Although the key to what constitutes a healthy diet depends on the individual, some people need certain vita mins, such as iron and potas sium, more than others, she says. Another example of a diet used by Texas A&M students is the Cambridge diet. Advertise ments claim that the Cambridge includes 100 percent of the mini mum daily requirements of vita mins and minerals, as well as 75 percent of the protein. The diet experts' objections are based on the restriction to 330 calories a day. For four weeks, the Cam bridge is the sole source of food. After that, it is used as a supple ment to a regular, controlled diet. "Any diet that has a disprop ortionate amount of any food group can be harmful," Dr. Hope says. "There is nothing healthy ab out a liquid protein diet — the Cambridge is just a variation of that. You can get sick in a hurry and most college students can't afford that." Another problem with the Cambridge is that it doesn't change the eating habits of the dieter, which is the secret to good dieting, Hope says. The Cambridge Diet may not change the eating habits of the individual, but Texas A&M stu dents interviewed seem to approve of the diet. Students seem to get interested in the Cambridge because of its quick results, and they don't appear to worry about damaging their health. "The Cambridge helps you lose weight fast and you get your vitamins to keep you from feeling drained — it never made me ill," Sharon H., a sophomore business major from Houston, says. Sharon, who was on the diet for two weeks, says that for her, the loss of a lot of water weight in the first three days gave her an incentive to stick with the diet. Sheila Davis, a junior aeros pace engineering major, who is a Cambridge counselor living in a dorm on campus, had as many as 35 customers at the beginning of the semester. She also thinks the diet's quick results give an incentive to the people she sells it to. However, a lot of her cus tomers need only to lose about 5 pounds, and once they accom plish that goal they go back to their old eating ways. She her self lost 6 pounds while on the diet strictly for two weeks, and has since kept the weight off. "I use it as a nutritional sup plement since I'm not on the meal plan, and just eating across the street in restaurants won't do it," Sheila says. Tammy ]., a Cambridge coun- :selor living in Sevilla apart- iments, says some of her custom- t?rs drink the Cambridge for a quick breakfast. Using a quick reducer such as the Cambridge is fine for some individuals, but not if you are looking for a permanent weight loss, Kubena says. In order to accomplish long—term weight loss, you must change your eat ing habits, or you may gain all the pounds back. "The point is that if you lose weight and gain it all back, you do more harm than good to your body," she says. People often practice this "yo—yo effect," which is fluctuating from losing weight to gaining it back plus a couple of pounds. The pros and cons of any diet depend on the individual, for weight problems result from a variety of factors. Aside from overindulgence, the cause of obesity can be psychological, or it could be a legitimate health problem. For that reason, before going on a diet, check with a doctor. In the past, the A.P. Beutel Health Center has diagnosed thyroid gland problems, or vitamin de ficiencies, both of which can contribute to a weight problem. A physical problem is as much cause of obesity as anything else, she said. "We at the coun seling center won't treat the psychological side of dieting un til students check that possibil ity," Hope says. Obesity can be caused by hormonal, genetic, or metabolic problems. There may be an imbalance of hormones, or a greater tendency for a person to accumulate body fat because of a slow metabolism. Hor mones are under the control of genes, which are inherited. Hope is also one of the psychologists at the Student Counseling Service who spon sors group therapy for people who want to change their atti tude about eating. Group support is an impor tant aspect of the weight control groups at the Student Counsel ing Service. That concept is also part of the philosophy of such groups as Weight Watchers and Overeaters Anonymous. The positive reinforcement a group can give the individual can help, especially since the family at home is not around at college to back you up, Hope says. Sometimes it's easier to get involved in a diet with some body else. But Kubena says the problem with a group is that its members begin to depend too much on the group for support, and once they try to be independent of it, they could gain the weight back. Layers of clothes key to warmth by Diane Yount Battalion Staff So, you thought you were going to have spring all win ter? Sun, shades, and coconut oil? Wrong! Cold weather blew into College Station Monday, ling ered around until Tuesday and decided to stay on. Oh, the sun will probably break through for a slight warming period, but count on a frigid fanny for the next few months. If you're worried about protecting that and other parts of your anatomy, re member, wind or tempera ture cannot be controlled, but clothing can. "Select clothing for your activities as well as for out door conditions," says Dr. Ann Vanderpoorten, clothing specialist with the Texas Agri cultural Extension Service. For people who love how to lists, there are a few stan dard precautions that should be taken to prevent frostbite. — The layer closest to the skin should be lightweight, usually cotton. — The second layer should be an insulation layer that will keep warm air trapped around the body. Bulky fab rics work best. — Blazers, windbreakers, shoes and waterproof pants should compose the out ermost layer. They should keep the other layers from getting wet. They should also be easily removable, in case the situation heats up. — A hat or hood is impor tant too. Up to 75 percent of body heat may be lost if the head is unprotected. If you enjoy being out doors, face the fact that for a while, the weather is going to be nippy. Dress appropri ately. And if you enjoy warmth, stay inside. And cuddle.